I respect Tony and his take on the state of the music industry mainly because he has been involved in that industry for some time. However, his problem is that he’s been involved in that industry for a long time.
It seems that the music industry, being ingrained in its ways for the last 60 years, is a product of its own stubbornness. Up until the mid 90’s, the industry was a well oiled machine. You would have a band… a starving band… playing little gigs until you were “discovered”. Then, you’d sign a big deal, get cash advances, go touring, spend all of your money, owe the label your soul, and fall into stark destitution while the label continued to profit off of your brief but violently shining career since you never owned your own material. They had total control of the product from start to finish and it was this cycle that kept sustaining itself indefinitely… until the dreaded Internet.
All of a sudden people could have access to music, instantly. All kinds of music was available. People would download tracks just for the novelty at first, then they did it because they could. Suddenly you had the ability to listen to an entire CD before deciding to buy it. I can’t count the times that I heard a good song on the radio and promptly went out to buy the CD just to discover that the song on the radio was the ONLY good track on the disk. Alas, just another cog of the well oiled machine… Bait and switch if you ask me.
Anyhow, some artists saw what was going on and decided to put an end to this. Metallica, for example, actively sought out traders (THEIR FANS) and sued them into oblivion. These people were still going to shows and buying merchandise…. but the sheer fact that the boat was rocked and the machine upset was enough to cause widespread panic (*cough* Y2K anyone?). The overall result? It has been nearly 10 years since and I haven’t heard about anything from Metallica for a LONG time…
And so begins the DRM. That cursed three letter word that makes life for the average person a living hell. However, how else to charge $.99 for a 15 second MIDI ringtone of a song you already own on CD, and probably cassette TAPE for some of you. DRM is man made. Anything made by man can be broken by man. If someone IS NOT going to buy a CD, they are simply not going to buy it. No matter how much or how little DRM is on a product, people that have no intention of buying music simply will not. However, the industry still thinks it can control the gas leak in their machine by applying more DRM to products. LET IT GO… just simply let it go.
The easier you make your product to use by the consumer, the more you will sell. Period. Why do you think MACs are still a presence in the computing world dominated by the PC? They are EASY to use (coming from a PC fanboy nonetheless). The main problem with the industry is its sheer unwillingness to conform to the public demand. Simply offer low priced DRM free digital downloads, and watch your profits go back up — even if you’re selling cookie cutter crap like Brittney Spears, 50cent, or any band trying to follow some actual original ideas and throwing the word “MUD” in their name for credibility.
I see the music industry at a very precarious crossroads similar to the photography industry…only I think they may have driven a few miles the wrong direction. Take Kodak for example. Their bread and butter has been film for many decades. When their old analog format started to die off in the place of digital photography, Kodak saw the changing tide and adapted. They didn’t try to sue anyone using a Digital SLR camera out of existence just to try to sell a FEW more rolls of film before people realized that film was obsolete. They didn’t try 1920’s “protection money” style heavy handed tactics to force consumers to “settle” with them or be sued. Kodak adapted its business model and is thriving.
I’m not very sympathetic to artists complaining about the market these days. I, being a musician myself, can appreciate musical quality. Most of what I hear in the “mainstream” today compared to music of just 10-15 years ago is just not that good. Musically, almost everything is in the same key (or in the same derivative family), use the same chord progressions, use simple time signatures, and can easily be interchanged aside from the singers and sound the same as everything else.
Perhaps the slowdown in CD sales is that the product is just uninteresting crap? After all, there are only so many teenage girls to buy the next boy band cd or gangsta wannabes to buy something with lyrics that wouldn’t pass 3rd grade English standards. Perhaps it is the simple fact that the industry seems to be targeting 10-18 year olds who’s population numbers are shrinking compared to 40-30 years ago. No, that can’t be…. that would mean the big machine is grinding to a halt — that would NEVER happen.